The bird flu virus spreading through dairy cattle in the United States may be expanding its reach via milking equipment, the people doing the milking, or both, U.S. Department of Agriculture (USDA) representatives reported today at an international, virtual meeting held to update the situation. The avian virus may not be spreading directly from cows breathing on cows, as some researchers have speculated, according to USDA scientists who took part in the meeting, organized jointly by the World Organisation for Animal Health and the United Nations’s Food and Agricultural Organization. “We haven’t seen any true indication that the cows are actively shedding virus and exposing it directly to other animals,” said USDA’s Mark Lyons, who directs ruminant health for the agency and presented some of its data. The finding might also point to ways to protect humans. So far one worker at a dairy farm with infected cattle was found to have the virus, but no other human cases have been confirmed.
USDA researchers tested milk, nasal swabs, and blood from cows at affected dairies and only found clear signals of the virus in the milk. “Right now, we don’t have evidence that the virus is actively replicating within the body of the cow other than the udder,” Suelee Robbe Austerman of USDA’s National Veterinary Services Laboratory told the gathering. The virus might be transmitted from cow to cow in milk droplets on dairy workers’ clothing or gloves, or in the suction cups attached to the udders for milking, Lyons said. (In a 30 March interview with Sciencenone, Thijs Kuiken, a leading avian influenza researcher at Erasmus Medical Center, had suggested the milking machines might be responsible because the components may not always be disinfected between cows.)
The influenza virus causing the outbreak, an H5N1 subtype that is known as clade 2.3.4.4b, has devastated wild birds and poultry around the world for more than 2 years, and researchers at first thought migratory birds were responsible for spreading it to all of the affected dairy farms. But USDA scientists now think the movement of cattle, which are frequently transported from the southern parts of the country to the Midwest and north in the spring, may also have played an important role. And they floated the possibility, without naming specific herds or locations, that all affected cows may trace back to a single farm. Since first revealing the infection of dairy cows with this bird flu virus on 25 March, USDA has confirmed it has spread to cattle in six states. And the agency has used the virus’ genetics to track its movements. The virus found on U.S. farms has a specific genetic signature, which led USDA to name it 3.13. “It’s not a common [strain], but it’s very much a descendant of the viruses that have been dominating the flyways in the Pacific and the central flyways in the United States,” Robbe Austerman said.
The USDA scientists reported that the agency’s analysis of the different viruses from the cows indicates they likely came from one source. Cows from infected farms in Texas appear to have moved the virus to farms in Idaho, Michigan, and Ohio. “The cow viruses so far have all been similar enough that it would be consistent with a single spillover event or a couple of very closely related spillover events,” Robbe Austerman said. “So far we don’t have any evidence that this is being introduced multiple times into the cows.” The virus in cows could spread to poultry, which has that industry on edge. USDA tightly regulates avian influenza virus strains that are deadly to poultry, requiring culling of entire flocks if one bird tests positive for this H5N1 or one of its relatives; to date, commercial and backyard poultry farms have had to cull 85 million birds because of this virus. But USDA is not calling for any such drastic measures with cow herds. In response to questions from Sciencenone, Ashley Peterson, who handles regulatory affairs for the National Chicken Council, said “out of an abundance of caution, we believe it is prudent to restrict the movement of cows from positive herds.” Although some researchers agree USDA should stop the transport of dairy cows, the agency has so far declined to take that disruptive action. “We heavily rely on the producers who have been isolating the animals within the dairy herds,” Lyons said. USDA also says it has no evidence of beef cattle becoming infected. USDA and the Food and Drug Administration have stressed that pasteurization kills viruses, so there is “no concern” about the safety of commercial milk. They do recommend people not consume raw milk or products made from it.
Sources tell Science none some dairy farms that were later shown to be infected first noticed dead cats as early as mid-February. The animals, which often drink spilled milk on farms, “were the canary in the mine,” one said. The cows’ milk was also unusually thick. Those signs, coupled with the discovery of dead birds on the farms, led to the testing of cow milk for the bird flu virus and the 25 March USDA announcement. Oddly, the dead birds on infected farms were not waterfowl, the migratory birds that typically spread the avian flu viruses to poultry, but “peridomestic” species such as grackles, blackbirds, and pigeons. One farm had the virus detected in poultry before it was found in its cows, and although Robbe Austerman said she hesitated to call it the “ancestral strain,” she noted that “all of the detection so far in cattle are clustered around that.” Further studies should clarify how the virus wound up in cows, which sometimes become infected with flu viruses but have never before been shown to have one that causes high mortality in birds. One possibility is that birds infected cows by shedding their droppings in the cows’ feed or water. But bird flu viruses in the past have also spread for many kilometers in the wind, moving from one poultry farm to another. So the current H5N1 strain could have moved from waterfowl to poultry to cattle—or directly from poultry to cattle and then even to the peridomestic birds. “This could be a multifactorial presentation that we’re seeing,” Lyons said. “Lots of questions still to be answered.”